Peer Review Process

Journal of Physical Education and Sport (JPES) is committed to maintaining the highest standards of editorial integrity, fairness, and scientific rigor. All submitted manuscripts undergo a strict double-blind peer-review process, in which the identities of both authors and reviewers remain concealed throughout evaluation.


1. Editorial Workflow

  • Initial Editorial Screening (Desk Review): Upon submission, the Editorial Office checks each manuscript for thematic alignment with the journal scope, technical formatting compliance, ethical documentation, and similarity index (maximum 20% excluding references). Manuscripts failing these initial checks are returned or desk-rejected without external review.
  • Reviewer Assignment: Manuscripts passing initial screening are assigned by the Editor-in-Chief or an Associate Editor to at least two independent, external experts in the relevant field who have no conflicts of interest with the authors.
  • Double-Blind Evaluation: Reviewers assess the scientific merit, methodology, statistical validity, originality, and clarity of the manuscript using the standardized JPES Evaluation Protocol.
  • Editorial Decision: Based on the reviewers' reports and total evaluation score, the Editor-in-Chief issues a formal decision. If reviewer recommendations conflict significantly, a third independent reviewer is consulted.
  • Revisions & Final Verification: Authors invited to revise their manuscript must submit a revised version along with a point-by-point response to all reviewer comments. Revised manuscripts may undergo a second round of review before final acceptance.

2. Estimated Review Timeline

JPES strives to provide a timely, transparent, and constructive evaluation process:

  • Initial Editorial Screening: 5 – 7 business days from submission.
  • First Editorial Decision (after Peer Review): 2 – 4 weeks from submission.
  • Author Revision Period: Up to 14 days for minor revisions; up to 30 days for major revisions.
  • Final Decision & Online Publication: 1 – 2 weeks following final acceptance and completion of production checks.

3. Evaluation Protocol (100-Point Scale)

Reviewers evaluate original research manuscripts across nine weighted criteria:

Evaluation Criterion

Maximum Score

1. Originality of the investigation

20 points

2. Scientific topicality

15 points

3. Applicability to current practice

15 points

4. Study design and methodology quality

10 points

5. Quality of disclosed results

10 points

6. Clarity and depth of discussions

10 points

7. Clarity of conclusions

10 points

8. Accuracy of citations and bibliography

5 points

9. General academic language quality

5 points

Total Score

100 points


4. Editorial Decisions

Based on the cumulative evaluation score and qualitative reviewer feedback, manuscripts receive one of four outcomes:

  • Rejection (< 50 points): The manuscript exhibits substantial methodological, ethical, or conceptual flaws and is declined for publication.
  • Major Revisions (50–70 points): The manuscript requires significant structural, analytical, or textual revisions and must undergo re-evaluation before a final publication decision is made.
  • Minor Revisions (> 70 points): The manuscript is scientifically sound and accepted subject to minor technical or editorial adjustments.
  • Acceptance without Modifications (> 70 points): The manuscript meets all scientific and editorial standards and is accepted directly for publication.

5. Reviewer Ethics, Confidentiality & Appeals

  • COPE Compliance: Reviewers and editors adhere strictly to the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers. Manuscripts are treated as confidential documents and may not be shared, cited, or used for personal research advantage prior to publication.
  • Conflicts of Interest: Reviewers must decline invitations if they have recent collaborations, institutional affiliations, or personal/financial relationships with any of the authors.
  • Editorial Independence: Special issue submissions and manuscripts authored by editorial board members undergo the exact same independent double-blind peer-review process, managed by an editor with no conflict of interest.
  • Appeals & Complaints: Authors who believe an editorial decision was based on a misunderstanding of the scientific content may submit a formal, evidence-based appeal to the Editorial Office (jpes@rosportart.ro). Appeals are reviewed independently by the Editor-in-Chief and an Associate Editor.